Our team advised Sibanye in the ConCourt matter of Sibanye/M Bester
Our team advised Sibanye in the ConCourt matter of Sibanye/M Bester
Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr represented Sibanye, the largest individual producer of gold from South Africa and one of 10 largest gold producers globally.
Our employment team advised Sibanye in the Constitutional Court matter of Sibanye/M Bester. The case relates to an assessment of racism in the workplace and, more particularly, deals with the question of direct and indirect racism. This dispute is not about defamation or injuria, but rather it focuses on statements which are actually racist or perceived to be racist in the workplace and which have the potential of causing divisions between workers and disrupting workplace harmony. The matter emanates from the Labour Appeal Court and was referred to the Constitutional Court on appeal.
You might also be interested in
31 Jan 2024
by Alex Kanyi and Billy Oloo
Tax stability and predictability for economic sustainability
Prior to deciding to introduce or redomicile a business in any country, an investor must always consider how favourable, stable, and predictable the country’s tax system is. The primary rationale for this is the need for certainty and guarantee regarding the future sustainability of investment in the host country. This predictability ensures that the investor can plan for their business, which includes planning ahead for tax liabilities and allocating resources appropriately and efficiently. On the other hand, a tax regime that is unstable and unpredictable has the opposite effect, that is, it hinders an investor’s power to consciously make investment decisions, which would ultimately be a deterrent, leading to capital flight and reduced economic activity. Foreign direct investment (FDI) is particularly sensitive to tax stability and predictability, as investors weigh the risks associated with potential changes in tax laws. Countries with consistent and transparent tax regimes are more likely to attract FDI, contributing to economic development and job creation.
Corporate & Commercial Law
4 min read
9 Jul 2024
by Nomlayo Mabhena-Mlilo
A prudent question is one half of wisdom: The consequences of business email compromise on individuals | Part 2
Modern day technology has afforded people the luxury of convenience. However, with this increased convenience has come an upsurge in cybercrime attacks against law firms, banks, individuals and other institutions. The most common forms of attack are ransomware attacks, hacking and phishing scams. In the first part of this alert, titled A prudent question is one half of wisdom: The consequences of business email compromise on banks and attorneys , we discussed the case of Hartog v Daly and Others (A5012/2022) ZAGPJHC 40; 2 All SA 156 (GJ) (24 January 2023), in which an attorney fell victim to fraudsters who intercepted email communication and provided false banking details. This resulted in the attorney making payment into a fraudulent account without further questioning the change in the details, leading to a claim against him by the rightful recipients of the funds, which claim was upheld by a full court. In this article, we discuss the case of Edward Nathan Sonnenberg Inc v Hawarden (Case no 421/23) ZASCA 90 (10 June 2024), in which the Supreme Court of Appeal (SCA) considered the liability of a law firm in respect of a claim for pure economic loss caused by an alleged negligent omission.
Dispute Resolution
4 min read
17 Jan 2024
by Ismail Makda, Akhona Mdunge, Jocelyn Lawrence-Kganane, David Pinnock and Yaniv Kleitman
Rogue directors counting the grains in the hourglass
There are many famous quotes about the passage of time, and miscreant directors may well be pondering a number of these in light of recent developments regarding the time-barring of claims based on breach of duty.
Corporate & Commercial Law
5 min read
24 Oct 2024
by Timothy Baker, Claudia Moser and Lara Sneddon
To institute or not to institute liquidation proceedings (that is the question)
It is a well-established principle in our law that insolvency/liquidation proceedings are not meant to be used for the recovery of a debt – the courts regard this as an abuse of (legal) process. Rather, the purpose of insolvency proceedings, as per Trengove AJ in Investec Bank Ltd and Another v Mutemeri and Another (O9/22247) ZAGPJHC 64 is “ to bring about a convergence of the claims in an insolvent estate to ensure that it is wound up in an orderly fashion and that creditors are treated equally ”.
Corporate Debt, Turnaround & Restructuring
5 min read
12 Nov 2024
by Neha Dhana, Ledile Maloka and Tyler Lillienfeldt
The conundrum of unsolicited bids
Municipalities regularly receive unsolicited bids, which are offers by third parties on their own initiative and without an invitation from a municipality to provide the municipality with goods or services. The general principle is that municipalities are not obliged to consider unsolicited bids as they fall outside the normal bidding process. In the circumstances, when a municipality does choose to consider an unsolicited bid it must do so within the prescribed legislative framework.
Dispute Resolution
3 min read
12 Aug 2024
by Thabang Rapuleng and Malesela Letwaba
Transfer or no transfer? A consideration of the provisions of section 197 of the LRA and dismissals that flow from it
Section 197(2) of the Labour Relations Act 66 of 1995 (LRA), amongst other things, states that if a transfer of a business takes place, unless otherwise agreed in terms of section 197(6), the new employer is automatically substituted in the place of the old employer in respect of all employment contracts in existence immediately before the date of the transfer.
Employment Law
6 min read