How to spot a scam: A discussion on emerging global risk trends
How to spot a scam: A discussion on emerging global risk trends
Another day, and yet another dollar you might lose to a new cryptocurrency or foreign exchange con that is gaining global popularity. The “Sha Zhu Pan” (meaning “Butchering the Pig”) scam first gained notoriety in China, but it has crossed the oceans and continents to make landfall in Australasia, Europe and the US, and is likely to arrive on South Africa’s shores shortly.
At a glance
- The "Sha Zhu Pan" scam, originating in China, has spread globally and is expected to reach South Africa soon. It involves a prolonged period of building trust with the target before extracting a significant sum of money and disappearing.
- The scam follows a pattern where the scammer initiates contact through social media, establishes a relationship, and then introduces the target to fraudulent cryptocurrency or foreign exchange investments.
- Targets are enticed by quick profits and the ability to withdraw funds initially, but eventually, they are asked to invest more money to withdraw their funds, leading to a complete loss and abandonment by the scammer and the investment company.
This is not your average con. Unlike the rapid in-and-out type of hustle which the world has become accustomed to, this scam appears to have direct similarities to Simon Leviev’s (of Tinder Swindler fame) successes. In this con, targets are affianced over a period of several months (the “fattening of the pig” so to speak) before the con artist extracts a significant sum of money out of them and then disappears (the proverbial “slaughter”).
The anatomy of the con plays itself out as follows
- The con artist (most often utilising a fictitious profile depicting an attractive person) will reach out to the target via any number of social media platforms.
- The social media engagement between the scammer and the target is craftily scripted on the scammer’s part and continues over a period of weeks or months while the scammer builds a “relationship” with the target and gains their trust.
- After the passing of a few months (and after having established a connection) the scammer then cunningly guides the romantic relationship or friendship conversation towards the subject of cryptocurrency or foreign exchange investments and the remarkable profits that the scammer has enjoyed by contributing in a specific “investment” (the scammer knows this to be fake company that the scammer has set up or has affiliations with).
- The target (emboldened by the scammer’s encouragement) deposits an amount into the suggested investment and is pleasantly surprised when significant apparent “profits” are quickly realised (utilising the amounts paid into the company by other innocent targets who have succumbed to stage 7 below). To deepen the target’s false sense of security, the target is even able to extract funds from the investment (making the investment seem “legitimate”).
- In gaining the target’s trust in the scam by demonstrating a quickly realisable profit (exceeding anything that can be achieved in the market) and allowing the target to withdraw the investment, the scammer is able to induce the target to invest a more sizable sum.
- Once the target has made their move and invested a sizeable sum (in the hope of quickly realising a prodigious profit margin), the scheme quickly starts to unravel, as the target is then advised (by a purported “customer services representative” of the investment company) that funds cannot be withdrawn (usually because of alleged capital gains tax implications) unless the target deposits further amounts into the “investment” in order to be entitled to withdraw the funds.
- Immediately upon receiving the target’s further “investment” (on top of the sizeable investment referenced in stage 6 above), the scammer and the investment company cut all communications with the target and the target is left holding the (by this stage very naked and cold) baby.
This carefully curated and pernicious scheme primarily preys on those individuals whose social media presence demonstrates that they have a degree of wealth (the scammers are on the lookout for photos of designer watches, handbags, exotic holidays and motor vehicles) and are social or are single – but the criteria is not limited to this. The scammer is also not necessarily looking to establish a romantic connection and even a friendship will suffice if the scammer sees that they can establish a “trust” relationship with the target.
We all wonder, how the target could be so blind to what is happening, but the scammers are intelligent and crafty. Statistics from an Australian sample survey suggest that the vast majority of people succumbing to the scam are under the age of 35 and have a bachelor’s degree from a university. Statistics from a US survey indicate that the vast majority of cases result in the target losing between 50 and 100% of their net worth to the scam. These statistics are indicative of the salacious intelligence of the scammers and with cybercrimes and fraudsters on the rise in South Africa, this is something we should all be alive to. Accenture has even identified that South Africa has the third-highest number of cybercrime victims worldwide, at a cost of R2,2 billion a year, with online scams in our top five cyber threats.
There have already been instances of this scam in Africa (although only a few), but with the rest of the world becoming alive to it, it is only a matter of time before the scammers focus their attention on South Africa.
The information and material published on this website is provided for general purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. We make every effort to ensure that the content is updated regularly and to offer the most current and accurate information. Please consult one of our lawyers on any specific legal problem or matter. We accept no responsibility for any loss or damage, whether direct or consequential, which may arise from reliance on the information contained in these pages. Please refer to our full terms and conditions. Copyright © 2023 Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr. All rights reserved. For permission to reproduce an article or publication, please contact us email@example.com.
We support our clients’ strategic and operational needs by offering innovative, integrated and high quality thought leadership. To stay up to date on the latest legal developments that may potentially impact your business, subscribe to our alerts, seminar and webinar invitations.Subscribe