Subsequent to this announcement there have been mixed messages from the government about who will qualify for a vaccine under this roll out. In an announcement that drew some criticism, the Minister of Health, Dr Zweli Mkhize, initially indicated that only South African citizens with identity documents would be entitled to receive the vaccine.
However, government appears to have reconsidered this decision. In his address to the nation on 1 February, in what appears to be an about turn, the President said the government aimed to make the vaccine available to all adults living in South Africa, regardless of their citizenship or residence status. He went on to state that, “We will be putting in place measures to deal with the challenge of undocumented migrants so that, as with all other people, we can properly record and track their vaccination history”.
This is in line with a statement made by the National Treasury Director-General Mr Dondo Mogajane on 24 January 2021, during a virtual meeting between his Department and the SA National Editors Forum in which Mr Mogajane said that foreign nationals including undocumented foreign nationals/persons would also benefit from the rollout of the COVID-19 vaccine: “We are in SA and we have many millions of undocumented people and [we can’t say they shouldn’t receive the vaccine as they are undocumented]. The demand for the vaccine is going to be exceeded, and we are not going to turn away undocumented people…”
These indications that the government will include undocumented persons in its vaccine roll out has been welcomed by Refugee and Migrant advocacy groups, some of whom were it seems already considering challenging the constitutionality of limiting the roll out to South African citizens.
Perhaps in making this announcement, the President was mindful of the Pretoria High Court’s decision just last year declaring the exclusion of asylum seekers and Zimbabwean and Lesotho special permit holders from the government’s COVID-19 social relief of distress grant to be unconstitutional; or that countless numbers of South African citizens are themselves for systemic reasons undocumented – and have neither a birth certificate nor an identity document.
Whatever the reason for the change in policy the decision is to be welcomed. Importantly, it signals a welcome departure from an increasingly exclusionary approach by our government to the treatment of undocumented persons (and foreign nationals) and accords with the spirit of our Constitution. On a more pragmatic level, given the purpose and intent behind the mass vaccine rollout, it seems that it would simply not be sensible to exclude a large portion of the population from the Programme.
It is clear from the President’s address that the purpose of the mass vaccination programme is to enable us to achieve population immunity (herd immunity). In his address, the President explained the government’s ambitious targets: “we will [by phase 3 of the programme] ... have reached around 40 million South Africans, which is considered to approximate herd immunity.” The President further intimated: “We have always said that an effective vaccine will be a game-changer. Vaccines offer to the peoples of the world a means to control the Coronavirus pandemic. A person who is vaccinated has a much-reduced chance of becoming ill and dying from COVID-19.”
Population immunity will be achieved when enough of the population is immune to the virus to provide indirect protection to those who are not immune, bringing the spread of the virus under control and importantly reducing pressure on our healthcare system. While the actual level needed for such immunity is, at this stage, unknown, scientists have estimated that South Africa will likely reach herd immunity once around 67% (approximately 40 million) of the population is immune.
Statistics on the number of foreign nationals (documented and undocumented) living in South Africa vary. According to Stats SA, the number of foreign-born people living in South Africa in 2020 is around 3,9 million. This includes both the documented and undocumented. The United Nations population division put the number at 4,2 million in 2019 – this it said represents about 7,2% of the population. According to Stats SA’s 2011 census, 6,2 million foreign nationals lived in South Africa, and the organisation’s 2015 estimate placed the number of undocumented migrants between 1,2 and 1,5 million.
Although there is no certainty as to the number of undocumented foreign nationals/persons living in South Africa today, it is a substantial number of people. Certainly, any decision to exclude undocumented persons would exclude a significant number of people. Furthermore, and important to emphasise, to exclude all undocumented persons would mean the exclusion of many innocent South African citizens, victim to the systemic obstacles preventing them from being documented.
But as laudable as this announcement is, the devil always lies in the detail and at the moment there is scant detail as to how the programme will be rolled out.
Given widely reported negative experiences that undocumented foreigners have in attempting to access health care in South Africa (many face routine unlawful discrimination in attempting to access healthcare), coupled with provisions in our immigration laws which allow immigration officials wide powers to arrest and deport “illegal” foreigners, much will need to be done not only to build the trust of foreign nationals if they are to participate in the roll out, but also train healthcare workers.
If the programme is to work as intended, the government needs to expeditiously provide more information about the roll out of the programme and consult with civil society in order to gain people’s trust.